Ayrt- I think it's cutting out a lot of interesting stuff like Hagelin/Zuckerello or Geno/Ovi play-off angst, and I think once you cut out those kinds of stories you end up with a more limited range of options. Sid is probably already the most ficced Penguin so I think you are going to end up with Sid/Sullivan Sid/Sheary Sid/A N Other.

I think an exchange that excludes Sid altogether would get more varied prompts.

But I'm not that much of a Pens person, perhaps there are loads of story ideas for the people I know nothing about.